I first learned about Dr. Attia through watching the series 'Limitless.' I found the series to be extremely inspiring, and ultimately life-changing. I then stumbled across a Youtube clip where someone was discussing this book, which led to my purchase of it. It is a very thick book with which I took my time reading, in chunks. (I did not read the last two sections on sleep and emotional health).
I read through some of the 1 and 2 star reviews on Goodreads. Many mentioned that the book could be significantly shorter and that they did not like all of the personal stories that Dr. Attia shared. However, I found each of the stories to be quite helpful in putting the information into context. And I think the overall intent of this book was/is two-fold. It was not only written to present 'information,' but also Dr. Attia's personal testament of his journey as he learned new things, changed his perspectives, struggles in life, etc. The addition of this deeply intimate information helps to make the book more personable versus cold and mechanic. And who knows, writing this book may have also provided Dr. Attia with some degree of inner peace and resolution. What is so wrong with that?
There are many focal points of this book, but for this book review, I will address what I find to be key take away points, and my perspective of those points discussed by Dr. Attia.
READABIITY: Some parts of the book could be difficult for people to understand if they do not have a medical background, fortunately I do. For those who do not, and really want to understand, have Internet access handy so that you can cross-reference between the Internet and the book as you go along. NOTE: There are many parts of the book where animal research studies are discussed. I must preface that I struggle reading about animal studies, as I am anti-animal testing activist. But I do understand why the studies are mentioned in the book.
PHILOSOPHY: Dr. Attia makes several comparisons between Medicine 2.0 and Medicine 3.0. I think many Primary Care providers who read and subsequently reviewed this book may have felt offended by Dr. Attia's views on what he describes as our current healthcare model (Medicine 2.0). However, Dr. Attia is not pointing fingers and intending to insult Primary Care providers. He is simply pointing out flaws in our current healthcare model and how it should shift to a different focus, which I 100% agree with!
For those who chose to be insulted by this, shame on you. If you are a Primary Care provider, it is also not your fault that your practice is based upon Medicine 2.0, as you have to operate within the restrictive system and in accordance with insurance coverage. Embrace the Medicine 3.0 philosophy and save it for the day when, perhaps, our current healthcare model will shift closer to it. Everyone will be better off for it.
PREVENTATIVE TESTS: I found it odd when a reviewer mentioned that they know many adults who lived to old ages without any fancy tests. That is a strange thing to write, because Dr. Attia does NOT imply that having a bunch of tests contributes to living longer or healthier. Conversely, he implies that having preventative tests provides knowledge of one's current health state. That knowledge can then enable people to make changes that can contribute to living longer and healthier versus being a ticking time bomb and continuing on the same physiological path. How that reviewer misconstrued these two vastly different concepts is beyond me. This reviewer continued on to say that these seniors also smoked, drank, ate what they wanted, etc. However, I cannot help but wonder about their quality of life, and whether they were active and enjoy(ed) pursing hobbies/interests OR if they were simply 'existing' as couch potatoes. These are two vastly different concepts, and is the focal point that Dr. Attia expresses throughout the book.
On another note, Dr. Attia describes the perfect world where everyone has access to a plethora of preventative tests. Many of these preventative tests (scans, blood, etc.) are not covered by typical insurance plans, which means people have to pay out of pocket for them. I do plan to have most of the screening tests done that he recommends, because I want that in-depth knowledge of my current health state. However, doing all of these are just out of reach for many, or until patients reach a certain age (DEXA scan, for example).
MACRO NUTRITION: As many others mentioned, I do not think that any new/novel information about macro nutrition was presented. Some reviewers got the impression that Dr. Attia is pro-Keto diet. But I did not infer that at all. Conversely, I thought Dr. Attia did a great job with pointing out key advantages and disadvantages of many different types of diets, not just Keto. And I think he made it quite clear that no one type of nutrition regimen/approach is going to work for everyone. This point was made quite clear when he discussed his friend/patient (the Lipidologist) who benefited from a fasting regimen. I also think he did a good job explaining how different macro nutrients affect the body in an easy to understand fashion. I particularly found the information about Fructose and Purine quite interesting.
EXERCISE: It was made abundantly clear that Dr. Attia believes that exercise is the foundation for good health, which I agree with! He describes, in detail, how exercise is the best preventative tool for the "Horsemen." Yes, it makes good sense: Exercise = improved blood flow = improved perfusion AND = building and/or maintenance of muscle tissue and maintenance of bone = potential reduced risk for the "Horseman." But in reality, is it really THAT simple? I do not think so. There are so many other factors that come into play.
Additionally, what is disheartening, and what other reviewers found discouraging about this, is how complex Dr. Attia makes exercise out to be. While I agree with the benefits of all the different types of exercises he discusses, I also think it is unrealistic for many people to achieve all of it in it's entirety. Again, it comes back to the perfect world where there are no life-stressors, no major time consuming life-demands, not having to work a full-time job, etc.
For example, let's talk about a rich celebrity who is one of Dr, Attia's patients: Chris Hemsworth. I am not criticizing or picking on Mr. Hemsworth. Below is just a great example that helps my point hit home here.
Does he work a 40-hour week desk job, staring at a computer all day? No. Is he on his feet all day working at a store helping customers? No. Does he come home from that job, after a commute, and have to try to squeeze in a workout? No.
Does he have personal trainers and nutritional coaches? Yes. Does he have plenty of time most days to exercise and enjoy leisurely activities? Yes. Is his job as an actor focused on being physically fit? Yes. Is he able to wake up naturally most days instead of being blasted awake by an alarm clock? Yes. Does he have plenty of income to not have to worry about paying the bills? Yes.
This is the perfect world that Dr. Attia describes. Not everyone has enough time in the day to devote to exercising like Dr. Attia believes is necessary. I am a poly-outdoorsman, and I am an endurance (non-professional) athlete. I would love nothing more than to have the amazing opportunity to devote as much time as I want to exercise and my outdoor sports versus working a full-time job. However, that is not my reality despite how much I would like it to be.
For most people who live in the real world, doing some exercise each day/week just has to be enough because that's all they can do. So to even remotely imply that that amount just isn't enough to obtain a long, healthy lifespan is quite sad. This is where the notion of 'weekend warriors' comes into play. For some, weekends are the only time that people have to exercise and/or recreate in the outdoors. This pattern does not align with Dr Attia's ideology, but doing something on the weekends is better than doing nothing at all.
What I do think readers can benefit and take away from this section of the book is to, perhaps, incorporate different exercises into their daily/weekly regimen that they may not have thought of. This is key! For myself, I have now incorporated new things into my exercise regimen because I have a better understanding of how they can have a long-term impact.
FINAL THOUGHTS: This is not a concrete book of science. It is a book that discusses some scientific information combined with Dr. Attia's life-experiences. I think it is a well-rounded book because of this. Take whatever information you found useful and run with it! Be as active as you possibly can each day/week, keep your body trim, and feed it with good nutrition. For us "Commoners," that is the best we can do.
下载免费的 Kindle 阅读软件，即可立即在智能手机、平板电脑或电脑上阅读 Kindle 电子书 - 无需 Kindle 设备。
使用 Kindle 网页版即时在浏览器上阅读。
使用手机摄像头 - 扫描以下代码并下载 Kindle 阅读软件。
Great on Kindle
绝佳体验。物超所值。
推出优质电子书
每本 Great on Kindle 电子书都能提供绝佳阅读体验，比纸书更物有所值，还省钱。
浏览电子书，然后使用“快速翻书”功能直接跳回上次离开的地方。
查看高质量图像，可放大仔细查看。
享受 只有数字版独有的功能——立即开始阅读，随身携带图书馆，调整字体，创建可共享的笔记和亮点等等。
集成维基百科，了解有关电子书中的事件、人物和地点的更多详细信息。
获取免费的 Kindle APP： 
购买本电子书（Kindle 版），享受绝佳阅读体验。 了解更多关于 Great on Kindle 的信息，可在特定类别中查看。
经常一起购买的商品
本商品: Outlive: The Science and Art of Longevity
US$18.00
12月13日 星期五即会收到商品
现在有货。
+
US$22.40
12月14日 星期六即会收到商品
现在有货。
+
US$11.31
12月14日 星期六即会收到商品
现在有货。
总价: $00
要查看我们的价格，请将这些商品添加到您的购物车。
选择要一起购买的商品。
购买此商品的顾客也同时购买
页码 1 / 1 从头开始页码 1 / 1
- Workbook for Outlive the Science and Art of Longevity: A Guide to Dr. Peter Attia's BookBrighter Health LLC平装亚马逊配送的订单满US$49免运费12月14日 星期六即会收到商品
- Good Energy: The Surprising Connection Between Metabolism and Limitless Health精装亚马逊配送的订单满US$49免运费12月14日 星期六即会收到商品
此书中的热门标注
Risk is not something to be avoided at all costs; rather, it’s something we need to understand, analyze, and work with.2,063 位 Kindle 读者已标注- One macronutrient, in particular, demands more of our attention than most people realize: not carbs, not fat, but protein becomes critically important as we age.1,942 位 Kindle 读者已标注
- First, Medicine 3.0 places a far greater emphasis on prevention than treatment.1,089 位 Kindle 读者已标注
来自出版社
|
|
|
|
|---|---|---|
|
|
|
|
视频
页数 1 总页数 1重新开始页数 1 总页数 1
10 key points from the book “Outlive”
The key points gained after reading the book "Outlive the Science and Art of Longevity" are as follows:1. Lifespan and healthspan should go hand in hand, emphasizing that a long and quality life requires good health, not just increasing numerical age.2. Major diseases affecting lifespan and healthspan include diabetes, metabolic diseases, Alzheimer's, cancer, and cardiovascular diseases—important non-communicable diseases in today's era.3. The essential concept for quality longevity is "Medicine 3.0," focusing on primary prevention to detect and manage diseases early.4. Proactive healthcare for a long health span and lifespan emphasizes prevention over reaction, addressing health before illness occurs.5. Developing health span involves adjusting five key aspects: physical activity, nutrition, sleep, emotional management, and drug/hormone supplementation.6. Individuals at high health risk, identified through genetic screening or specialized lab tests, should seriously adopt healthy behaviors to reduce future risks.7. The content in general is about adjusting health behaviors. It is similar to non-fiction health books. If you have read them before, the concept of care is almost no different. What is different is that it emphasizes screening for high-risk groups and providing proactive care for this group, managing from the beginning. In real life, testing according to this concept is still difficult. It can only be done by people with money, so there is a high inequality. And there is no medical or research data to support this concept, even though it has a good rationale (the book says it is both science and art, the science and art of longevity).8. The missing part of health care according to the concept of Medicine 3.0 is the prevention of infectious diseases or communicable diseases, which many diseases are preventable (such as COVID, influenza, pneumococcal bacteria, dengue fever, hepatitis A, B, hemorrhagic fever, etc.) by using vaccines or drugs. But the author ignores this important point. Not sure if it is because of the commercial issue or not. Because if you recommend getting vaccinated to prevent diseases, it may make the anti-vax group feel anti this book. The author does not touch on this point, which is also important in increasing lifespan along with health span, especially for the elderly. As you get older, your immunity to various diseases decreases, and you are more likely to get infected.9. Some content conflicts, such as criticizing observational research limitations while selectively using similar studies. Confirmation bias may be influencing the author's perspective.10. The book may give off an influencer vibe, sharing personal health practices and encouraging readers to follow the author's health program, potentially for commercial purposes.In conclusion, the belief that lifespan and health span should align is shared, but the significance of a meaningful and purposeful life is crucial.
